Reformer removed - Page 2

Environmental health director led progressive programs, resigned after mysterious investigation


Sources familiar with the situation told the Guardian the investigation started with a whistleblower complaint filed against Bhatia, which led department officials to try and determine whether there was a conflict of interest associated with his role as a nonprofit board director.

But Bhatia reacted strongly to this allegation, which was also alluded to in a San Francisco Chronicle article. "It's just not true," he said. "I'm not on the board of any nonprofit that receives any money from the city."

Some high-ranking health department officials do work with nonprofit organizations that deal closely with the city. As the Bay Guardian previously reported ("Friends in the Shadows," Oct. 8, 2013), Chawla is a board member of the San Francisco Public Health Foundation, which raises funds for DPH and functions as a city contractor. Sue Currin and Roland Pickens, CEO and COO of San Francisco General Hospital, respectively, serve on the board of the San Francisco General Hospital Foundation. The vast majority of private donations to the city's safety-net hospital are collected through that nonprofit entity.

Bhatia sits on the board of Human Impact Partners, an Oakland-based nonprofit with 11 staff members dedicated to tackling health equity issues. "I was pretty careful to draw the line," he said of that role.

"I think the real question is, for me, what facts did the city use to justify their actions? It seems arbitrary," Bhatia said. "As far as I know, all of the work I was doing was part of the mayor's agenda. This came out of nowhere, and it apparently has no basis."

Last October, a group of his professional colleagues wrote to the health department to voice concern that his removal would cause key environmental health programs to fall by the wayside.

Among the initiatives he was moving forward was a Community Air Pollution Risk Reduction plan, which sought to establish new policies for alleviating respiratory problems associated with air pollution hotspots. Since concentrated air pollution occurs within some of the city's priority residential development areas, that new set of proposed regulations would apply to new and existing real-estate development projects.

"The City began drafting the [risk reduction plan] in 2010 and was to have adopted a plan by 2012," supporters wrote in an Oct. 1 letter. "We are puzzled by a recent City presentation on the timeline for the CRRP, which suggested that a plan was not yet drafted."

Chawla said the plan continues to move forward. She also acknowledged that, in general, Bhatia "has really brought a lot of great ideas and work to the health department, and that is something I value and anticipate will continue."

The air pollution risk reduction plan wasn't the only place where Bhatia's work overlapped with development and housing issues. Adelman described how Bhatia had conducted a health impact assessment, a formal study to determine the health outcome of a policy decision, on the potential health benefits of requiring developers to build onsite affordable housing units as part of new construction projects.

He was also engaged in an effort to improve the environmental health division's code enforcement against housing hazards, such as mold and pests, and pushed for an open data initiative to make housing inspection records publicly available.

"We don't really want to believe this is happening," Paloma Pavel, president of Earth House Center and cofounder of Breakthrough Communities, said of the investigation against Bhatia and his subsequent departure. Patel and cofounder Carl Anthony, both former directors of the Ford Foundation, authored a book and created a nonprofit dedicated to advancing environmental justice and regional health equity.

"It's a terrific loss for our region's environmental health," she said of Bhatia's departure.


Also from this author

  • Waiting for answers

    Community calls for justice and transparency in police shooting of Nieto after new eyewitness contradicts SFPD version

  • Federal complaint filed over death of Alex Nieto as supporters vow to keep fighting

  • Department of Homeland Security issues security bulletin over peaceful protest